A Bear Market Rally?

Stocks did pretty well last week.  Given the backdrop of another interest rate reduction and the Microsoft bid for Yahoo the fact that stocks were up should be of little surprise.  The issue is whether this was the beginning of a climb back up or just a rally in a bear market.  I lean to the view that this current period of strength is a great selling opportunity.  There are still way too many problems on the economic horizon that will have to be resolved before stocks can sustain an uptrend. 

Thanks MSFT

If not for the MSFT bid for Yahoo the market, as I suspected, would have reacted very negatively to the jobs report.  Job creation in January was actually in negative territory, suggesting a very weak economy.  Who knows, maybe we are headed for a recession?  However, the prospect of more M&A activity may prove a good counter force to an economic slowdown.   Not as bearish as earlier today.

Good Bye, Good Riddance

It was a horror.  It caused sleepless nights.  It was painful. It was often irrational.  No, I’m not talking about the prospect of John McCain having access to the nuclear code, but the month of January 2008 for stock investors.  From the first trading day of the new year it has been an almost steady decline in equity prices.  The S&P 500 had its worst January since 1990, and the Nasdaq had its weakest start to a year EVER.  So yesterday, some institutions did some window shopping for some bargains, found them among the home builders and some financials, and the market ended January on an up note.  I’m not impressed.  It will take more than some bottom fishing to convince me their are serious buyers entering the market.  By, the way there is lots of cash on the side-lines, but I don’t think it will be put to work just yet. I’m still expecting more near term downside.  Today’s employment report can produce that very easily.

Mixed Signals

The Fed did what most people expected yesterday and lowered interest rates another 50 basis points.  The stock market initially celebrated and then in keeping with the recent history of volatility, ended the day on the downside.  The debate still rages about the economy, that many folks think is headed for a recession, or already is in one.  Well, I guess we are old fashioned but we believe that a recession is defined as two consecutive quarters of lower GNP.  That has not happened, nor is it likely.  Employment is holding up rather well, and aside from the housing sector, the economy is in reasonably good shape.  There are problems in the credit markets that are serious and must be factored into any outlook for equity prices.  It has been a horrible January and having been on the Street for more years than I care to remember, and old saying goes, " As goes January so goes the market for the year".  If that’s the case there is still a lot of hurt coming for stock prices.  In my opinion, I would be using any rallies in the market as a chance to lighten long positions.  Don’t panic but be prudent.

Buckle Your Seat Belts

For investors
2007 was a year of bi-poplar extremes that has left many market participants
emotionally and in some cases financially exhausted. In all the years that we have toiled on Wall Street we have never seen
such extreme market movements like those that evolved over 2007. Still, when all
the dust has settled the “average” stock will have been up for the year and
despite the “mega” economic and financial problems that are currently
impacting the U.S. economy. Indeed
given the current environment we believe the stock market has behaved rather
well. Does this suggest that 2008
will be the year that reality finally sinks in on investors?

Indeed,
economic reality is not very good right now. A lot of greedy and supposedly
smart bankers lent money to folks who were very high risk. Now the folks who wanted in on the housing boom and saying that they
didn’t understand the risk and therefore the government should protect them
from foreclosure. Of course the
government is more than happy to oblige thereby putting one more nail in the
coffin of free markets, while not solving the underlying credit problems. If we were to see a major blowup – say, several financial institutions
simultaneously taking large and unexpected losses in sub-prime or other risky
debt – already-anxious lenders could drastically cut back on new loans and cause
a real credit crunch. That could prompt both consumers and corporations to
dramatically lower their spending, which could be the catalyst that sends the
economy spiraling downward and into recession. At the same time the US dollar has been in free fall reflecting the
global view that U.S. economy is a mess. Oil
spiked to the $100 per barrel level in 2007 once again punctuating the rising
cost of energy and the failure of anyone in power to really address the
longer-term energy outlook. All of this negativity has spooked the American
consumer and spending is beginning to slow down, making the risk of a recession
very real. And the potential icing on the cake is a bunch Democrats
running for president who cannot wait to raise taxes. If one acknowledges that all of the points raised above are not good news
for the stock market, we wonder how any reasonable investor can be bullish for
2008?

To
be sure, the bullish among us will point to the moderate valuation of stocks as
reason to be optimistic. And we
admit that valuations are attractive, but traditional analytic measures may not
apply when such mega-problems loom in the immediate future. If the economy
were just on the verge of recession we could handle that since that is just part
of the normal business cycle. However,
when the possibility of economic slowdown is combined with tighter credit and
high energy costs we begin to really worry. Our view is that it would be prudent to reduce the exposure to stocks. So
buckle your seat belts, it’s going to be a bumpy 2008.